Updated October 30, 2026 · Written by the installation team at Vision Aluminum & Glass Specialists, licensed Florida contractor CGC 1537007
Quick answer
Both protect your openings, and both can qualify for the insurance opening-protection credit when they are approved products and cover every opening. Impact windows are always in place, so there is nothing to do before a storm, and they add security, noise reduction and energy savings, but they cost more up front. Shutters cost less but have to be closed before every storm. Many South Florida homeowners combine them: impact glass where they live every day, shutters on rarely used openings.
How do impact windows and shutters protect a house?
In a hurricane, the biggest danger to a home is a broken opening. Once wind-borne debris breaks a window or slider, wind rushes inside, pressure builds against the roof from below and the walls from within, and a broken window can turn into a lost roof. Every form of opening protection exists to keep that first opening sealed.
Impact windows do it with the glass itself: laminated glass bonded to a strong interlayer, set in a reinforced frame. If debris hits, the glass may crack, but the interlayer holds it in the opening. Shutters do it with a barrier in front of an ordinary window: a panel, curtain or set of slats that takes the hit so the glass behind it never does.
Side-by-side comparison
| Impact windows & doors | Hurricane shutters | |
|---|---|---|
| Protection when you are away or asleep | Always on — nothing to deploy | Only if someone closed them in time |
| Storm preparation | None | From minutes (accordion, roll-down) to hours (storm panels) |
| Everyday benefits | Security, noise reduction, UV and heat control | None when open |
| Insurance opening-protection credit | Yes, when every opening is protected with approved products | Yes, when every opening is protected with approved products |
| Light and views during a storm | Unchanged | Blocked while closed |
| Upfront cost | Higher | Lower |
| Approval and permit | Product approval and building permit required | Product approval and permit required for permanent shutters |
What types of hurricane shutters are there?
| Shutter type | How it works | Good to know |
|---|---|---|
| Accordion | Folding panels stored beside the window, pulled closed and locked | Fast to close by one person; visible when stored |
| Roll-down | Curtain of slats in a box above the opening, manual or motorized | Easiest to deploy, especially motorized; higher cost |
| Storm panels | Removable aluminum or steel panels mounted on tracks | Lowest cost; heavy and slow to put up, need storage |
| Bahama and colonial | Hinged decorative shutters that close over the window | Architectural look; Bahama styles also give shade |
What do impact windows and shutters cost?
Our 2026 South Florida price guide puts standard impact windows at about $850–$1,850 each installed and a typical 12–20-opening home at roughly $16,500–$40,000. Shutters cost less: one published 2026 guide lists accordion shutters at about $400–$800 per opening and roll-down shutters at about $800–$1,800, with storm panels usually the least expensive option. Prices depend on opening size, product approval and whether the work is on an upper floor.
Not sure which is right for your home? We quote both.
Vision Aluminum & Glass Specialists — rated 4.9★ from 55 Google reviews. Licensed Florida contractor CGC 1537007, serving Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach County since 2014. Free, no-obligation estimates.
Which one qualifies for the insurance discount?
Both can. Florida insurers apply an opening-protection credit when a wind mitigation inspector documents that every opening is protected with approved impact-rated products. The key word is every: windows, entry doors, sliding doors, skylights and the garage door. A single unprotected opening can lower the rating for the whole house. Our wind mitigation guide explains how the inspection works.
When do shutters make more sense?
- Openings you rarely use or look through, such as a garage-side window or a utility room.
- Rental properties where the owner, not the tenant, controls storm preparation.
- A tighter budget, where protecting every opening with shutters now beats protecting half the house with impact glass.
- Second homes, if a property manager is reliably available to close them — or if they are motorized roll-downs.
When do impact windows make more sense?
- You travel during hurricane season, or nobody in the house can safely put up panels.
- You want the everyday benefits: break-in resistance, a quieter house and less heat through the glass.
- Large sliders and picture windows where you never want to lose the view.
- You are replacing old windows anyway, so the upgrade cost is only the difference.
The hybrid approach most homeowners choose
There is no rule that a house must use one method. A common South Florida plan is impact windows and an impact front door on the main living areas, an impact sliding door to the patio, and aluminum shutters on a few rarely used openings. As long as every opening ends up protected with approved products, the house can qualify for the full opening-protection credit — and the budget goes where you feel it every day.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do impact windows also need hurricane shutters?
No. Approved impact windows and doors count as opening protection on their own, so the openings they cover do not need shutters.
Are shutters as safe as impact windows?
Approved shutters protect the opening when they are closed. The difference is that impact windows are always protecting the house, while shutters only protect it if they were closed before the storm.
Do I need a permit for hurricane shutters?
Permanently installed shutters are usually installed under a building permit and must be approved products. We handle the permit as part of the job.
Can I mix impact windows and shutters and still get the insurance credit?
Yes. The credit depends on every opening being protected with approved products, not on using one method everywhere.
Related: Hurricane protection package · Impact window replacement · Aluminum shutters · 2026 price guide
Ready for a free, measured quote?
Vision Aluminum & Glass Specialists — rated 4.9★ from 55 Google reviews. Licensed Florida contractor CGC 1537007, serving Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach County since 2014. Free, no-obligation estimates.
